Home→Europe→MEPs boycott NGO funding report that found no wrongdoing
Europe

MEPs boycott NGO funding report that found no wrongdoing

A year-long European Parliament probe found no evidence of financial misconduct by NGOs or the European Commission, yet its report recommends new restrictions on some civil society funding. Centre and left-wing MEPs boycotted its presentation on Wednesday, 18 November, calling the process politically motivated.

The 71-page report was presented by its authors, Dutch centre-right MEP Dirk Gotink and Italian conservative Carlo Fidanza, to right-wing MEPs after groups from S&D, Renew Europe, The Greens/EFA and The Left stayed away. In a joint statement, the four groups called the Scrutiny Working Group (SWG) “a political instrument” for undermining civil society and accused it of violating Parliament’s rules on confidentiality and democratic participation. They said no amendments would be allowed before the Committee on Budgetary Control votes on the report.

Although the authors found no proof of wrongdoing or financial misconduct by NGOs or the Commission, and no evidence that EU authorities required funded NGOs to conduct advocacy, their report proposes 23 recommendations. These include five-year funding bans for organisations lobbying EU and national institutions, phasing out core operating support, and administrative ring-fencing requirements. Gotink said some proposals should apply only to a limited number of NGOs that “behave very much like the consultants.” He added: “We want civil society to engage,” but said groups should not seek to influence legislative outcomes with amendments.

Gotink argued that EU funds should not go to NGOs that lobby MEPs or take legal action to enforce EU law. In February, however, he said the inquiry was not about establishing illegality, but whether conduct was “politically undesirable.” Fidanza called for the next long-term EU budget to ensure “not a single euro” of public money was spent without benefiting European citizens.

The boycotting MEPs said scrutiny should cover all beneficiaries if transparency was the concern. Gotink acknowledged the group could have examined Commission consultancy contracts “much more,” adding that if the “big four” stopped working for the Commission, it would “simply stop[] working.” The dispute comes amid a sharp funding imbalance: major industry lobbyists including Meta, Amazon, Apple, Shell and Bayer spend at least €381.75 million annually on EU lobbying, according to Corporate Europe Observatory and LobbyControl. Environmental NGOs receive about €15.6 million a year in LIFE programme operating grants, according to media reports. UN special envoy Gina Romero warned that restricting operating grants risks weakening civil society and agendas important to the EU.

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

No comments yet. Be the first!